I Inherited a Coin Collection — Now What?
A calm, step-by-step plan to figure out what you have, what it's worth, and what to do next.
Inheriting a coin collection is overwhelming — most are a mix of common coins worth face value and a few genuinely valuable pieces. The right first move is not to sell or clean anything. Instead: organize, identify, triage for value, and only then decide what to grade or sell.
First rule: don't clean the coins
Cleaning is the most common and costly mistake. It can turn a valuable coin into a "details" coin worth a fraction of its potential. See what coins should not be cleaned.
The 5-step plan
Don't clean anything
Cleaning coins almost always lowers their value — professional graders detect it instantly and assign reduced 'details' grades. Resist the urge to make coins shiny.
Organize and inventory
Sort by denomination and era. Keep coins in their existing holders. Photograph everything so you have a record before anything moves.
Identify what you have
Separate the common from the potentially valuable using our coin-type guides — Morgan dollars, Lincoln cents, Buffalo nickels, Mercury dimes and more. Note dates and mint marks.
Triage for value
Apply the 3X rule and pre-grade the collection with AI to surface the handful of coins actually worth professional grading — and flag the common ones that aren't.
Decide: keep, grade, or sell
Grade the few that clear the math; sell the rest raw. Don't accept the first lowball offer from a 'we buy gold' shop.
Triage the whole collection free
Photograph your coins and let AI surface the few worth professional grading — no signup required.
Start Grading Free